Jump to content

Controversy over the title of the 1987 Brazilian football champion

Edit links
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

The controversy over the title of the 1987 Brazilian football champion stems from differing interpretations regarding the winner of the Copa União, resulting from organizational issues during the competition. The Brazilian Football Confederation awards the title for that year to Sport, while Clube dos 13 recognizes Flamengo as the champion. Some Brazilian sports outlets, such as Revista Placar, consider both clubs as co-champions. In March 2018, the Supreme Federal Court issued a final ruling, rejecting Flamengo's appeal for the third time and confirming Sport as the champion.

Historical Context

[edit]

In 1987, the Brazilian Football Confederation was experiencing a severe financial and institutional crisis. On July 7, its president publicly announced that the organization was unable to hold a national championship that year in the same format as the previous one. Efforts were being made to secure sponsorship, and in the event of failure, the Brazilian Football Confederation proposed an agreement with clubs to cover their own travel expenses or, failing that, to organize a regionalized competition similar to the Taça Brasil era.

In response, Brazil's thirteen leading clubs sought a more profitable championship and, fearing the worst, formed a new entity called Clube dos 13 to organize their own tournament. This competition was named Copa União, a title that ultimately became synonymous with the 1987 Brazilian Championship.

The 1987 Tournament

[edit]

The conflict persisted primarily because of Flamengo. Despite a final ruling by the Federal Regional Court of Pernambuco declaring Sport the champion, Flamengo pursued legal action. They obtained an injunction preventing Caixa Econômica Federal from awarding the "Taça das Bolinhas" trophy to São Paulo, which had become a five-time champion in 2007. Flamengo claimed that the trophy had not been contested since 1992.[1]

On February 21, 2011, the Brazilian Football Confederation officially recognized Flamengo's 1987 title, declaring that there were two official champions that year.[2] However, on June 14 of the same year, following a court order from Pernambuco, the Brazilian Football Confederation reverted its position, once again recognizing Sport as the sole champion.[3]

When reporting Flamengo's 2019 Brazilian Championship victory on its official website, the Brazilian Football Confederation listed "1987 (Copa União)" among Flamengo's titles, alongside their championships from 1983 and 1992.[4]

Judicial Disputes and Continued Recognition

[edit]

Three years later, on April 8, 2014, the Superior Court of Justice upheld the decision that Sport was the sole 1987 champion.[5]

In 2015, the case reached the Supreme Federal Court. The case was assigned to Justice Marco Aurélio Mello, a known Flamengo supporter who did not recuse himself from the case.[6]

That same year, the Brazilian Football Confederation "split" the title in its Official Guide, contradicting the Superior Court of Justice's ruling by listing both Flamengo and Sport as champions in the 12th page of its 2015 edition. This guide included all unified national champions.[7] While the Brazilian Football Confederation officially recognized Sport as the 1987 champion, it argued that recognizing Flamengo as well would not contradict the limits of the judicial ruling. However, the Brazilian Football Confederation stated that it complied with the court's decision to recognize Sport as the sole champion out of legal obligation.

It is worth noting that the Brazilian Football Confederation's official recognition of titles occurs through Presidential Resolutions, not through the Official Guide. The guide even includes a bibliography section citing external sources (including Wikipedia), which are not official Brazilian Football Confederation documents.

On March 4, 2016, the Supreme Federal Court rejected the division of the title and upheld Sport as the sole 1987 champion.[8] Flamengo appealed this decision, and a new trial was scheduled for August 2016. However, it was postponed by Justice Luís Roberto Barroso, who stated he needed more time to review the case.[9]

The trial finally took place on April 18, 2017. By a vote of 3-1, the Supreme Federal Court's First Panel rejected Flamengo's appeal and reaffirmed Sport as the sole 1987 champion.[10] While Flamengo could still challenge this decision, the likelihood of reversal was considered virtually nil.

On December 5, 2017, the Supreme Federal Court reaffirmed its earlier ruling, and on March 16, 2018, the decision was finalized, leaving Flamengo with no further recourse.[11]

The 2021 Debate

[edit]

On February 25, 2021, after Flamengo's 2020 Brazilian Championship win, the Brazilian Football Confederation published an article on its official website celebrating the victory.[12][13] At the end of the article, the Brazilian Football Confederation listed Flamengo's national titles, including the 1987 Copa União. This highlighted the Brazilian Football Confederation's ongoing recognition of the Copa União as part of the Brazilian Championship, despite the Supreme Federal Court's final ruling.[14][15]

References

[edit]
  1. ^ "Todos os campeões da Taça das Bolinhas – Blog de Esportes" (in Brazilian Portuguese). 2016-03-15. Retrieved 2024-11-21.
  2. ^ Janeiro, Por GLOBOESPORTE COM Rio de (2011-02-21). "CBF volta atrás e reconhece o Flamengo como campeão em 1987". globoesporte.com. Retrieved 2024-11-21.
  3. ^ "CBF cumpre decisão judicial e reconhece Sport como campeão brasileiro de 1987 - 15/06/2011 - UOL Esporte - Futebol". www.uol.com.br. Retrieved 2024-11-21.
  4. ^ "Flamengo é campeão do Brasileirão 2019".
  5. ^ CastroRecife, Por Elton de (2014-04-08). "STJ anula resolução da CBF e mantém Sport como único campeão de 1987". globoesporte.com (in Brazilian Portuguese). Retrieved 2024-11-21.
  6. ^ "Marco Aurélio Mello: "Não se agradece a indicação com a capa"". GZH (in Brazilian Portuguese). 2015-05-16. Retrieved 2024-11-21.
  7. ^ "Guia da CBF divide título brasileiro de 1987 entre Sport e Flamengo – Blog de Esportes" (in Brazilian Portuguese). 2015-08-28. Retrieved 2024-11-21.
  8. ^ "Fla sofre derrota na Justiça, e Sport é declarado único campeão de 1987". www.uol.com.br (in Brazilian Portuguese). Retrieved 2024-11-21.
  9. ^ DF, Por GloboEsporte comBrasília (2016-08-02). "STF suspende julgamento de recurso do Flamengo sobre Brasileiro de 1987". globoesporte.com (in Brazilian Portuguese). Retrieved 2024-11-21.
  10. ^ "STF nega recurso do Flamengo e mantém Sport como campeão de 1987". www.uol.com.br (in Brazilian Portuguese). Retrieved 2024-11-21.
  11. ^ "De novo, STF confirma o Sport como único campeão brasileiro de 1987". Estadão (in Brazilian Portuguese). Retrieved 2024-11-21.
  12. ^ admin (2018-03-17). "Flamengo perde em última instância e Sport é o campeão brasileiro de 1987". Gazeta Esportiva (in Brazilian Portuguese). Retrieved 2024-11-21.
  13. ^ "1987: transitado em julgado (de novo) – Blog de Esportes" (in Brazilian Portuguese). 2018-03-17. Retrieved 2024-11-22.
  14. ^ "Com bicampeonato, Flamengo quebra tabu de 38 anos no Brasileirão Assaí".
  15. ^ "Brasileirão". brasileiraobetano.com.br (in Brazilian Portuguese). Retrieved 2024-11-22.

See also

[edit]
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Controversy_over_the_title_of_the_1987_Brazilian_football_champion&oldid=1258855988"