Mordechai Dov Brody

Mordechai Dov Brody (September 10, 1996 – November 4 or 15, 2008),^[1]^{[note 1]} nicknamed Motl or Motyl, was a 12-year-old Hasidic Jewish boy from Brooklyn, New York, United States.

After a brain tumor stopped his brain functioning, doctors declared him legally dead on November 4, 2008, but his parents refused to accept the legal definition of death on religious grounds because his heart was still beating.^[2] The case became the center of a widely publicized, but never resolved, legal dispute between his parents, Eluzer and Miriam Brody, and Children's National Medical Center, Washington, D.C.^[3]

Position of the hospital

According to an affidavit filed by one of his doctors, Brody's condition had deteriorated beyond a persistent vegetative state.^[4] He was pronounced brain dead and was unable to breathe on his own without the help of a ventilator. His heart beat on its own, but he required medication to maintain his blood pressure (normally a function of the brain stem).^[5] As a result, Brody's physicians wished to remove the boy from life support, as they believed he was brain dead, which is the legal definition of death in the District of Columbia.^[6]

Position of the parents

Although there is no consensus about what defines death in Jewish law, the parents are followers of rabbi Chaim Jacob Tauber, chief rabbinical judge of the Bobov Hasidic community in Brooklyn and they reject brain death as an indicator of death.^[7] They wanted their son to remain on a ventilator as long as his heart was beating.^[7] As the case deals with the definition of death, rather than the value of living in a permanent vegetative state, it was far more like that of Jesse Koochin^[8] than that of Terri Schiavo.

Legal proceedings

The hospital asked Judge William Jackson of the Superior Court of the District of Columbia to affirm the doctors' decision that the boy could be taken off life support.^[6] Brody's parents challenged the hospital's assertion that Brody was dead, and claimed that doing so would be a violation of the Religious Freedom Restoration Act.^[5]^[6] The judge heard initial arguments on November 10, but delayed issuing a decision until further hearings could be held.^[6]^[9] The family and the hospital also released a joint statement where they expressed their mutual hope for an out of court decision.^[9]

Cardiac death

Brody's heart stopped on November 15, 2008, and he was buried on November 16.^[10] The state of New York ruled November 4 his date of death.^[1] The court case was never resolved.

Notes

^ Doctors declared Brody legally dead on November 4, which is his official date of death. His parents and others in his Hasidic community consider his date of death to be November 15, when his heart stopped beating.

References

^ ^a ^b Social Security Death Index, 1935-2014. Social Security Administration.
^ "US legal battle over brain-dead child to resume on Thursday". AFP. November 10, 2008. Retrieved November 13, 2008.
^ Wilber, Del Quentin (November 6, 2008). "D.C. Hospital Sues to Remove Boy, 12, from Life Support". Washington Post.
^ "Medical Advances Complicate Definition Of Death". National Public Radio.
^ ^a ^b "A Medical Judgment". The Washington Post. November 10, 2008. pp. A16.
^ ^a ^b ^c ^d Alexander, Keith L. (November 11, 2008). "Judge Delays Decision on Removing Life Support". The Washington Post. pp. B05.
^ ^a ^b Labbé-DeBose, Theola; Brown, David; Alexander, Keith (November 7, 2008). "Jewish Law's Meaning of Death Nears Court Fight". The Washington Post.
^ Appel, Jacob M. (2005). "Defining Death: When Physicians and Families Differ". Journal of Medical Ethics. 31 (11): 641–2, discussion 642–4. doi:10.1136/jme.2005.011718. PMC 1734056. PMID 16269560.
^ ^a ^b Alexander, Keith L. (November 13, 2008). "District Briefing". The Washington Post. pp. B04.
^ "Brain-dead NYC boy at center of care controversy dies - USATODAY.com". usatoday.com. November 16, 2008. Retrieved November 17, 2008.

v t e Medical ethics cases
Assisted suicide	Betty and George Coumbias Dax Cowart Giovanni Nuvoli Sue Rodriguez Ramón Sampedro Piergiorgio Welby Jack Kevorkian
Euthanasia/ Withholding treatment	Andrew Bedner Tony Bland Paul Brophy Carol Carr Baby Doe Law Eluana Englaro June Hartley Vincent Lambert Robert Latimer Baby M Haleigh Poutre Karen Ann Quinlan Terri Schiavo Gloria Taylor
Medical opinion against parent/patient/guardian	Betancourt v. Trinitas Hospital Commonwealth v. Twitchell Mordechai Dov Brody Lantz v. Coleman Alfie Evans case Archie Battersbee case Charlie Gard case Tirhas Habtegiris Rom Houben Sun Hudson case Baby K Ashya King case Jesse Koochin Joseph Maraachli case Jahi McMath case Sarah Murnaghan Spiro Nikolouzos case Aruna Shanbaug case David Vetter
Informed consent to treatment	Ashley Treatment Gillick competence Marion's Case Schloendorff v. Society of New York Hospital Christiane Völling
Research	Abdullahi v. Pfizer, Inc. Albert Stevens Albert Kligman's dermatology experiments David Reimer Deep sleep therapy Doctors' Trial Guatemala syphilis experiment Henrietta Lacks Human radiation experiments J. Marion Sims Jesse Gelsinger Joseph Gilbert Hamilton Moore v. Regents of the University of California Surgery to try to improve mental health Medical Experimentation on Black Americans Milgram experiment Monster Study Radioactive iodine experiments Skid Row Cancer Study Stanford prison experiment Study 329 Plutonium injections Tuskegee Syphilis Study Willowbrook State School Greenberg v. Miami Children's Hospital Research Institute