Barrier troops

Barrier troops, blocking units, or anti-retreat forces are military units that are located in the rear or on the front line (behind the main forces) to maintain military discipline, prevent the flight of servicemen from the battlefield, capture spies, saboteurs and deserters, and return troops who flee from the battlefield or lag behind their units.

According to research by Jason Lyall of Princeton University, barrier troops are more likely to be used by the militaries of states that discriminate against the ethnic groups that comprise the state's military.^[1]

National Revolutionary Army

During the Battle of Nanking of the Second Sino-Japanese War, a battalion in the New 36th Division of the National Revolutionary Army (NRA) of China was stationed at the Yijiang Gate with orders to guard the gate and "let no one through". On 12 December 1937, the NRA collapsed in the face of an offensive by the Imperial Japanese Army (IJA), and various units attempted to retreat without orders through the gate. The battalion responded by opening fire and killing a large number of the retreating NRA units and fleeing civilians.^[2]

Soviet Red Army

In the Red Army of the Russian SFSR and later the Soviet Union, the concept of barrier troops first arose in August 1918 with the formation of the заградительные отряды (zagraditelnye otriady), translated as "blocking troops" or "anti-retreat detachments" (Russian: заградотряды, заградительные отряды, отряды заграждения).^[3] The barrier troops comprised personnel drawn from the Cheka secret police punitive detachments or from regular Red Army infantry regiments.^{[citation needed]}

The first use of the barrier troops by the Red Army occurred in the late summer and fall of 1918 in the Eastern front during the Russian Civil War, when People's Commissar of Military and Naval Affairs (War Commissar) Leon Trotsky of the Communist Bolshevik government authorized Mikhail Tukhachevsky, the commander of the 1st Army, to station blocking detachments behind unreliable Red Army infantry regiments in the 1st Red Army, with orders to shoot if front-line troops either deserted or retreated without permission.^[3]

In December 1918, Trotsky ordered that detachments of additional barrier troops be raised for attachment to each infantry formation in the Red Army. On December 18 he cabled:

How do things stand with the blocking units? As far as I am aware they have not been included in our establishment and it appears they have no personnel. It is absolutely essential that we have at least an embryonic network of blocking units and that we work out a procedure for bringing them up to strength and deploying them.^[3]

The barrier troops were also used to enforce Bolshevik control over food supplies in areas controlled by the Red Army as part of Lenin's war communism policies, a role which soon earned them the hatred of the Russian civilian population.^[4]

In 1919, 612 "hardcore" deserters of the total 837,000 draft dodgers and deserters were executed following Trotsky's draconian measures.^[5] According to Figes, "a majority of deserters (most registered as "weak-willed") were handed back to the military authorities, and formed into units for transfer to one of the rear armies or directly to the front". Even those registered as "malicious" deserters were returned to the ranks when the demand for reinforcements became desperate". Forges also noted that the Red Army instituted amnesty weeks to prohibit punitive measures against desertion which encouraged the voluntary return of 98,000-132,000 deserters to the army.^[6]

The concept was re-introduced on a large scale during the Second World War.^[7] On June 27, 1941, in response to reports of unit disintegration in battle and desertion from the ranks in the Soviet Red Army, the 3rd Department (military counterintelligence of Soviet Army) of the People's Commissariat of Defense of the Soviet Union (NKO) issued a directive establishing mobile barrier forces composed of NKVD secret police personnel to operate on roads, railways, forests, etc. for the purpose of catching "deserters and suspicious persons".^[8]^[9] With the continued deterioration of the military situation in the face of the German offensive of 1941, NKVD detachments acquired a new mission: to prevent the unauthorized withdrawal of Red Army forces from the battle line.^[8]^[9] The first troops of this kind were formed in the Bryansk Front on September 5, 1941.^{[citation needed]}

On September 12, 1941 Joseph Stalin issued the Stavka Directive No. 1919 (Директива Ставки ВГК №001919) concerning the creation of barrier troops in rifle divisions of the Southwestern Front, to suppress panic retreats. Each Red Army division was to have an anti-retreat detachment equipped with transport totaling one company for each regiment. Their primary goal was to maintain strict military discipline and to prevent disintegration of the front line by any means.^[10] These barrier troops were usually formed from ordinary military units and placed under NKVD command.^{[citation needed]}

In 1942, after Stavka Directive No. 227 (Директива Ставки ВГК №227), issued on 28 July 1942, set up penal battalions, anti-retreat detachments were used to prevent withdrawal or desertion by penal units as well. Penal military unit personnel were always rearguarded by NKVD anti-retreat detachments, and not by regular Red Army infantry forces.^[8] As per Order No. 227, each Army should have had 3–5 barrier squads of up to 200 persons each.

A report to the Commissar General of State Security (NKVD chief) Lavrentiy Beria on 10 October 1941 noted that since the beginning of the war, NKVD anti-retreat troops had detained a total of 657,364 retreating, spies, traitors, instigators and deserting personnel, of which 25,878 were arrested (of which 10,201 were sentenced to death by court martial and the rest were returned to active duty).^[11]

At times, barrier troops were involved in battle operations along with regular soldiers, as noted by Aleksandr Vasilevsky in his directive N 157338 from October 1, 1942.^{[citation needed]}

Order No. 227 also stipulated the capture or shooting of "cowards" and fleeing panicked troops at the rear of the blocking detachments, who in the first three months shot 1,000 penal troops and sent 24,993 more to penal battalions.^[12] By October 1942, the idea of regular blocking detachments was quietly dropped^{[citation needed]}, and on 29 October 1944 Stalin officially ordered the disbanding of the units, although they continued to be utilized in a semi-official capacity until 1945.^[13]

Practice and results of use

According to an official letter addressed in October 1941 to Lavrentiy Beria, in the period between the beginning of Operation Barbarossa to early December 1941, NKVD detachments had detained 657,364 servicemen who had fallen behind their lines and fled from the front. Of these detainees, 25,878 were arrested, and the remaining 632,486 were formed in units and sent back to the front. Among those arrested included accused 1505 spies, 308 saboteurs, 2621 traitors, 2643 "cowards and alarmists", 3987 distributors of "provocative rumors", and 4371 others. 10,201 of them were shot, meaning approximately 1.5% of those arrested were sentenced by military tribunals to death.^[14]

Richard Overy mentions the total number of those sentenced to be shot during the war was 158,000.^[15]

For a thorough check of the Red Army soldiers who were in captivity or surrounded by the enemy, by the decision of the State Defense Committee No. 1069ss of December 27, 1941, army collection and forwarding points were established in each army and special camps of the NKVD were organized.^[16] In 1941–1942, 27 special camps were created, but in connection with the inspection and shipment of verified servicemen to the front, they were gradually eliminated (by the beginning of 1943, only 7 special camps were operating). According to Soviet official data, 177,081 former prisoners of war and surrounded men were sent to special camps in 1942.^{[citation needed]} After checking by special departments of the NKVD, 150,521 people were transferred to the Red Army.^{[citation needed]}

On 29 October 1944, Order No. 0349 of the People's Commissar for Defense I. V. Stalin, the barrage detachments were disbanded due to a significant change in the situation at the front. Personnel joined the rifle units.^[13]^[17]

Syrian Army

It has been reported that in the initial stages of the Syrian civil war, regular soldiers sent to subdue protesters were surrounded by an outer cordon manned by forces known to be loyal to the regime, with orders to shoot those who refused their orders or attempted to flee.^[18]^[19]^{[non-primary source needed]}

Ukrainian Army

After the left flank around the city of Hirnyk collapsed in September 2024, the 210th Battalion of the 120th Territorial Defense Brigade attempted to withdraw but a blocking detachment from the 110th Mechanized Brigade threatened them with severe disciplinary actions or execution if they retreated.^[20]^[21]^[22]^[23]^[24]

Russian Ground Forces

Fedir Venislavsky, a member of the Ukrainian parliament's committee on national security and defence claimed that the Russian Ground Forces used Chechen personnel from the 141st Special Motorized Regiment as barrier troops to shoot deserters who tried to leave combat zones during the full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022.^[25]^[26] In October 2022, Ukrainian intelligence published a purported phone call where a Russian soldier described both his task of killing inmates, recruited from prisons by the Wagner Group, if they were retreating, and how he would be killed by others if he himself retreated.^[27] In November, the British Ministry of Defence claimed that Russia was using blocking units.^[28]^[29] In a video appeal to Russian President Vladimir Putin published on 25 March 2023, members of a unit tasked with assaulting Vuhledar claimed that their commanders were utilizing anti-retreat troops to force them to advance or risk being shot.^[30] In October 2023 member of Russian Duma Gennady Semigin openly praised Kadyrovite units role as barrier troops in Ukraine, a fact that was widely known but previously avoided in public debate in Russia. In response he faced widespread criticism and accusations that he implies Russian soldiers are cowardly.^[31]

In film

The 2001 film Enemy at the Gates shows Soviet Red Army commissars and barrier troops using a PM M1910 alongside their own small arms to gun down the few retreating survivors of a failed charge on a German position during the Battle of Stalingrad. The film misrepresents the role of blocking detachments in the Red Army. Although there was Order No. 227 (Russian: Директива Ставки ВГК №227) that became the rallying cry of "Not a step back!" (Russian: Ни шагу назад!, romanized: Ni shagu nazad!),^[32] machine gunners were not placed behind regular troops with orders to kill anyone who retreated, and they were used only for penal troops. As per Order No. 227, each detachment would have between three and five barrier squads per 200 personnel.^[33]^[34]

The 2011 South Korean film My Way also depicts Soviet blocking troops shooting retreating soldiers during a charge.^{[citation needed]}

The 2020 Chinese film The Eight Hundred depicts Nationalist Soldiers shooting deserters during the Battle of Shanghai.^[35]

References

^ Lyall, Jason (2020). Divided Armies: Inequality and Battlefield Performance in Modern War. Vol. 164. Princeton University Press. doi:10.2307/j.ctvn96h88. ISBN 978-0-691-19244-4. JSTOR j.ctvn96h88. S2CID 242123389.
^ Lai, Benjamin (2017). Shanghai and Nanjing 1937: Massacre on the Yangtze. Osprey Publishing. pp. 76–77. ISBN 978-1-4728-1749-5.
^ ^a ^b ^c Dmitri Volkogonov, Trotsky: The Eternal Revolutionary, transl. and edited by Harold Shukman, HarperCollins Publishers, London (1996), p. 180
^ Lih, Lars T., Bread and Authority in Russia, 1914–1921, University of California Press (1990), p. 131
^ Reese, Roger R. (3 October 2023). Russia's Army: A History from the Napoleonic Wars to the War in Ukraine. University of Oklahoma Press. p. 109. ISBN 978-0-8061-9356-4.
^ Figes, Orlando (1990). "The Red Army and Mass Mobilization during the Russian Civil War 1918-1920". Past & Present (129): 168–211. doi:10.1093/past/129.1.168. ISSN 0031-2746. JSTOR 650938.
^ Overy, R. J., The Dictators: Hitler's Germany and Stalin's Russia, W. W. Norton & Company (2004), ISBN 0-393-02030-4, ISBN 978-0-393-02030-4, p. 535
^ ^a ^b ^c Stephan, Robert, "Smersh: Soviet Military Counter-Intelligence during the Second World War", Journal of Contemporary History, Vol. 22, No. 4, Intelligence Services during the Second World War: Part 2 (October, 1987), pp. 585–613
^ ^a ^b Holley, David, "Exhibit in Moscow Celebrates a Soviet-Era Intelligence Agency", "Interview of Vadim Telitsyn", Los Angeles Times, 25 May 2003, Section A-3
^ Mawdsley, Evan, The Stalin Years: The Soviet Union 1929–1953, Manchester University Press (2003), ISBN 0-7190-6377-9, ISBN 978-0-7190-6377-0, p. 135
^ A. Toptygin, Neizvestny Beria (Moscow and St. Petersburg, 2002), p. 121
^ Roberts, Geoffrey (2006). Stalin's Wars: From World War to Cold War, 1939–1953. Yale University Press. p. 132. ISBN 0-300-11204-1.
^ ^a ^b "Приказ о расформировании отдельных заградительных отрядов. 29 октября 1944 г." [Order on the disbanding of separate blocking detachments]. docs.historyrussia.org. 2020-08-17. Archived from the original on 2022-12-22. Retrieved 2019-03-31. Отдельные заградительные отряды к 15 ноября 1944 года расформировать. Личный состав расформированных отрядов использовать на пополнение стрелковых дивизий.
^ "Справка С.Р. Мильштейна Л.П. Берии о количестве арестованных и расстрелянных военнослужащих, отставших от своих частей и бежавших с фронта. Октябрь 1941 г." [Note from S.R. Milstein to L.P. Beria on number of arrested and shot servicemen, who fell behind their units and fled from the front. October 1941.]. docs.historyrussia.org. 2022-03-08. Archived from the original on 2023-02-08. Retrieved 2023-02-08. С началом войны по 10-е октября с.г. Особыми отделами НКВД и заградительными отрядами войск НКВД по охране тыла задержано 657 364 военнослужащих, отставших от своих частей и бежавших с фронта. ... По постановлениям Особых отделов и по приговорам Военных трибуналов расстреляно 10 201 человек, из них расстреляно перед строем — 3321 человек.
^ Overy, R.J. (1998). Russia's War: A History of the Soviet Effort: 1941-1945. Penguin Books. ISBN 9780140271690.
^ "Постановление ГКО СССР № 1069 о мерах по выявлению среди бывших военнослужащих Красной армии, находившихся в плену и в окружении, изменников родине, шпионов и дезертиров. 27 декабря 1941 г., Москва" [Decision of the State Defense Committee of the Soviet Union № 1069 on measures of detecting traitors to the motherland, spies and deserters among former Red Army servicemen, who were held in captivity and were surrounded. 27 December 1941, Moscow]. docs.historyrussia.org. 2021-12-15. Archived from the original on 2023-02-08. Retrieved 2023-02-08.
^ "Приказ наркома обороны СССР № 0349 «О расформировании отдельных заградительных отрядов». 29 октября 1944 г." [Order of People's Commissariat of Defence of the Soviet Union № 0349 "On disbandment of barrier-troop detachments". 29th October 1944]. docs.historyrussia.org. 2021-12-06. Archived from the original on 2023-02-08. Retrieved 2023-02-08. Отдельные заградительные отряды к 15 ноября 1944 года расформировать. Личный состав расформированных отрядов использовать на пополнение стрелковых дивизий.
^ Taylor, William (2014). Military Responses to the Arab Uprisings and the Future of Civil-Military Relations in the Middle East (1st ed.). New York: Palgrave Macmillan. pp. 93–94. ISBN 978-1-349-48889-6.
^ Burns, Sean (2018). Revolutions and Military in the Arab Spring. London: I.B.Tauris. p. 213.
^ "." antikor.com.ua.
^ "." antikor.com.ua.
^ "Ukraine: A wave of desertions turns into an avalanche amid the US elections". World Socialist Web Site. November 15, 2024.
^ "Why is Syrskyi unable to hold the front? | Censor.NET".
^ "Abandoned on the Frontline: Inside the 210th Battalion's Struggle". 26 October 2024.
^ "The Kadyrovtsy act as anti-retreat forces for Russian troops near Kyiv". LB.ua. 2022-03-11. Retrieved 2022-11-01.
^ "Кадыровские "заградотряды" в Украине" [Kadyrov's "detachments" in Ukraine]. kavkazr.com (in Russian). 2022-03-22. Retrieved 2022-11-01. Kadyrov's men hold back soldiers of other units fleeing the battlefield
^ Quinn, Allison (2022-10-27). "Russia Now Has a Second Frontline Set Up Just to Kill Its Deserters: Intel". news.yahoo.com. Retrieved 2022-10-27.
^ Cecil, Nicholas (2022-11-04). "Putin's 'blocking units' threatening to shoot Russian deserters in Ukraine, says UK". Evening Standard. Retrieved 2022-11-05.
^ Post, Kyiv (March 14, 2023). "'Execution on the Spot' - Russian Commanders Threatening to Shoot Troops for Refusing to Fight". Kyiv Post.
^ "'They threatened to shoot us if we didn't advance' — Russian soldiers deployed near Ukraine's Vuhledar ask Putin for help". Novaya Gazeta Europe (in Russian). 26 March 2023. Retrieved 26 March 2023.
^ Gazeta.ua (2023-10-02). ""Кадиров створює загородзагони" – депутат РФ відкрив страшну правду". Gazeta.ua (in Ukrainian). Retrieved 2023-10-06.
^ Reese, Roger (2014). "Review: Enemy at the Gates". Society for Military History. Retrieved 2022-10-07.
^ Timofeychev, Alexey (2019-02-04). "'Enemy at the Gates' – How accurately was the Battle of Stalingrad portrayed in the film?". Russia Beyond. Retrieved 2022-10-07.
^ Robert, Stephan (1987). "Smersh: Soviet Military Counter-Intelligence during the Second World War". Journal of Contemporary History. 22 (4): 585–613. doi:10.1177/002200948702200403. S2CID 159160922.
^ "Review: Controversial Chinese blockbuster The Eight Hundred arrives at Canadian theatres spoiling for a fight". August 28, 2020 – via www.theglobeandmail.com.