Jump to content

Killing of Abdel Fattah al-Sharif

Coordinates: 31°31′25″N 35°06′13″E / 31.5236°N 35.1037°E / 31.5236; 35.1037
Extended-protected article
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
(Redirected from Abdel al-Fattah al-Sharif)
"Hebron shooting incident" redirects here. For Other incidents in Hebron, see Israeli–Palestinian conflict in Hebron.

Killing of Abdel Fattah al-Sharif
Part of the Israeli–Palestinian conflict (2015–2016)
Date24 March 2016
Deaths2 (1 attacker shot before the incident)
Injured1 (Israeli soldier wounded before the incident)
VictimAbdel Fattah al-Sharif
PerpetratorElor Azaria
VerdictFound guilty
Convictions18 months' imprisonment, 12 months' probation, rank demotion
ChargesManslaughter

On March 24, 2016, Elor Azaria, an Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) soldier, fatally shot Abdel Fattah al-Sharif, a Palestinian, in the head as the latter lay wounded on the ground in the Tel Rumeida neighborhood of Hebron. Al-Sharif had stabbed an Israeli soldier. Azaria was arrested and the Israeli Military Police opened an investigation against him for the charge of murder, but later reduced the charge to manslaughter.

The soldier's act sparked widespread public debate in Israel, that became a continuation of an already widespread debate over how one should implement the rules of engagement orders in the wake of the wave of Palestinian political violence.

Azaria was convicted of manslaughter and sentenced to 18 months' imprisonment, twelve months' probation, plus a demotion in rank.[1] He was released from prison after serving nine months.[2]

Incident

Site of the shooting, several months before the incident

On 24 March 2016, two Palestinians armed with knives, Ramzi Aziz al-Tamimi al-Qasrawi and Abdel Fattah al-Sharif, approached an Israeli military post manned by soldiers of the Shimshon Battalion of the IDF's Kfir Brigade in the Tel Rumeida neighborhood of Hebron and stabbed an Israeli soldier in the hand and shoulder, moderately injuring him.[3] The soldiers opened fire, killing al-Qasrawi and seriously injuring al-Sharif.

A few minutes later, reinforcements arrived, including Elor Azaria, a medic from the battalion. Azaria approached the wounded al-Sharif and fatally shot him in the head while standing less than two meters away.[4][5] A video of Azaria killing al-Sharif was published by B'Tselem,[6] and went viral on Israeli social media, sparking controversy.[7]

Investigation and trial

Following the shooting, Azaria's company commander, Major Tom Naaman, reported it to the battalion commander, Lieutenant Colonel David Shapira, who in turn reported it to the commander of the Kfir Brigade, Colonel Guy Hazut. Four hours after the incident, an initial investigation was opened and Azaria was suspended from duty. After the video was posted to social media, and after a report by Colonel Hazut was submitted to Chief Military Advocate General Sharon Afek, a military police investigation was opened and Azaria was detained.[8] Azaria was initially treated as a murder suspect,[7] but on 31 March, prosecutors told a court they were looking into manslaughter charges.[9] The initial investigation found that the shooting occurred three minutes after IDF soldiers shot and neutralized the knife-wielding assailants and pathologists ruled that Azaria's shot was responsible for the assailant's death and not his previous wounds.[6] An IDF investigation whose details were revealed on March 27 found that Azaria had said the assailant "needs to die" before killing him. At trial, a fellow unit member testified that this was said after the shooting.[10] In his testimony, Azaria denied he said that, and suggested other things he said may have been misinterpreted.[11] The investigation also found that fellow soldiers had tried to calm him.[12]

During a court hearing on 24 March, Azaria's attorney said the soldier feared the assailant had an explosive vest hidden under his shirt. IDF officials rejected this, saying the assailants had already been checked for explosives and that Azaria did not follow the procedures for such concerns before opening fire. During the investigation, Azaria also claimed that the assailant tried to reach for a knife that was "within reach" of him, while video footage showed the knife was a significant distance away from the assailant, who was critically injured.[13]

On 31 March, military judge Lieutenant Colonel Ronen Shor ordered the shooter released from jail to open arrest at his base, the headquarters of the Kfir Brigade. The judge, however, stayed this decision until the next day while the prosecution, which wanted his detention extended for a week, appealed against the decision. He was also barred from making any contact with the witness or carrying a gun.[14] The prosecution's appeal was rejected on 1 April, with the shooter being transferred to open arrest on his base. A further appeal hearing by a military appeals court was set on 5 April.[15] The military appeals court upheld the decision of the lower court on 5 April.[16]

On 3 April, it was reported that both the Israeli and Palestinian pathologists had determined that it was Azaria's bullet which killed al-Sharif.[17][18] It was also noted by the prosecution that the temperature during the incident was cold, debunking claims that the wearing of a coat by al-Sharif made it suspicious that he might be wearing an explosive vest.[19] The military prosecution announced on 14 April that the soldier will be charged with manslaughter.[20] Azaria's identity had been kept under gag order, which was lifted on 18 April following his indictment.[21] Vice News obtained a classified IDF document concerning the killing. The document described internal investigations concluding that Azaria had actually killed al-Sharif because he felt that "he needs to die" since he was a terrorist. The report stated that both Palestinian assailants had already been checked by another soldier before Azaria's arrival at the scene. It also stated that Azaria had changed his version of events during his questioning, stating that he shot the assailant because he felt that there was a threat to his life.[22]

The trial opened on 9 May in a Jaffa court and Azaria was charged with manslaughter and conduct unbecoming of a noncommissioned officer.[23] He denied the charge of manslaughter during his arraignment on May 23, pleading not guilty.[24] The body of al-Sharif was returned to his family for his funeral, which was held on 28 May. On 29 May, Azaria's defence team demanded the body be returned, arguing its absence hampered legal proceedings.[25][26]

IDF's lead investigator testified in court on 1 June that an ambulance driver, Ofer Ohana, who took many videos of the incident, had moved a knife thought to have been used in the earlier stabbing closer to al-Sharif and tampered with evidence to make it look like Azaria had killed him in self-defence. The prosecution's video footage revealed that the knife was lying three to four metres away from the injured al-Sharif and was thus out of his reach both before and after the shooting. Ohana, who was filming the incident, stopped his video after the shooting, moved the knife and then started the video again. The prosecution also showed additional footage which showed Azaria shaking hands with far-right activist Baruch Marzel. The lead investigator also stated that Azaria had sent a text message to his father, telling him that he made sure that the injured al-Sharif was killed. The prosecution showed footage which appeared to show Ohana kicking the knife towards al-Sharif after the shooting. Military prosecutors took a statement from Ohana and confiscated his phone after filing a warrant request in court.[27][28] According to testimonies by eyewitnesses, the second attacker was also executed with a shot to head while lying on the ground after being incapacitated.[29] A forensics expert testifying before the court on 8 June said that the video of the incident showing Azaria shooting al-Sharif had not been tampered with. Azaria's lawyer alleged that Imad Abu Shamsyieh, who documented the killing, wasn't there by happenstance. He also said that his son had been arrested a month and a half ago. Shamsyieh responded that his son had indeed been arrested but he had been released by the police later and hadn't done anything wrong.[30] Azaria's commander, Major Tom Naaman, testified before the court on 16 June that the victim posed no danger and Azaria had said that the victim needed to die.[31]

On 16 June, Dr. Hadas Gips, a pathologist from the Abu Kabir Forensic Institute, testified before the court. She stated that bleeding in al-Sharif's brain suggested that his heart was still beating when the bullet fired by Azaria hit his head. She also claimed that the rest of his wounds were not immediately fatal and that he could have been saved had he been given medical treatment. When questioned by the defence team about the potential consequences of the shootings which preceded the one by Azaria, Gips stated that even after a shooting to the head which paralyzes the brain centers, the heart continues to beat sporadically. So if al-Sharif was shot in the head beforehand, there wouldn't be bleeding in other parts of the body that are not in the brain.[31][clarification needed] She stated that the shot to the head was the last shot.[clarification needed] In response to the question of whether there could be movement in the limbs after the brain fails to function, she replied that there could be small muscle cramps but that she had have reservations about this and that it was outside her area of expertise.[32]

On 5 July, Ohana was questioned by prosecutors. When questioned about the conversation he had with the Azaria's father, he refused to divulge any details. When asked about the knife used by al-Sharif being moved, he answered that he had moved the knife closer after it had been moved further away from its original location by an ambulance driving away so that al-Sharif wouldn't be claimed to be another innocent person shot by Israelis. The prosecution, however, showed a video in which the knife was still far from al-Sharif's body even after the ambulance arrived. It also alleged that both Ohana and Azaria had attempted to cover up the fact that the shooting was in revenge and that he had told Azaria to lie to the police. Ohana denied this and claimed he only told Azaria he would help him get a lawyer. The prosecution further claimed that Ohana lied when he said he thought that al-Sharif had a bomb, because he would not have moved so close to his body if that was the case.[33][34]

Colonel Yariv Ben-Ezra, the commander of Hebron Brigades at the time of shooting, testified on 6 July that the shooting was unwarranted and that there were no explosives.[35]

On 11 July, a soldier present at the scene testified that he saw Azaria cock his gun and heard him say that al-Sharif deserved to die.[36]

David Shapira, another superior of Azaria who was present at the scene, testified on 12 July that Azaria never mentioned a bomb threat and only stated his fear of the knife next to the stabber. Shapira further stated that when he asked Azaria after the shooting about why he didn't kick away the knife, he responded that he felt threatened. Shapira stated that he then told Azaria that he didn't believe him and Azaria fell silent.[37][38]

On 24 July, Azaria was cross-examined for the first time by the prosecution. Azaria claimed that he shot al-Sharif when he started moving as he feared he might detonate an explosive device or would try to reach the knife near him.[39] On 25 July, Azaria admitted that the knife was not near al-Sharif, contradicting his earlier claim that it was. He also claimed that Tom Naaman had lied and stated Shapira was only involved second-hand.[clarification needed][40]

On 26 July, the final day of the cross-examination, Azaria denied that his motive for shooting al-Sharif was revenge and claimed that Shapira was lying. He said that the reason he shot al-Sharif was that people were shouting that al-Sharif had a bomb on him and that al-Sharif made him suspicious.[41] Later in the evening, when questioned by the judges about why he didn't shoot earlier if he thought al-Sharif posed a danger to others, he replied that he didn't know. He also dismissed the videos submitted as evidence.[42]

On 23 August, senior IDF Reserves officers Uzi Dayan, Shmuel Zakai and Dan Bitton, who were set to testify on Azaria's behalf, submitted their declarations to the court, which were subsequently leaked to the public. Dayan stated that the investigation against Azaria was unjustified and that the command as well as the management of the scene should be blamed. Zakai stated that the pictures of the incident certified that the prosecution was in error, and that Azaria acted out of a reasonable concern that al-Sharif may have been carrying a bomb. He blamed IDF command for the incident, asserting that they acted contrary to instructions. He also criticized Defense Minister Moshe Ya'alon, IDF Chief of Staff, IDF Spokesperson as well as the Senior Command for their behavior after the incident, claiming it destroyed any chance of Azaria receiving a fair trial. Dan Bitton criticized officers at the scene of the incident and argued that a "wrong verdict" will lead to a situation in which no soldier will be able to shoot to save lives. Azaria's legal team criticized the leak of their declarations, claiming it was done to prevent them from testifying for Azaria.[43]

On 28 August, Eliyahu Liebman, civilian security chief for Jewish settlers in Hebron, testified. He backed Azaria's claim that al-Sharif present a threat as he was wearing a jacket on a hot day and said that the description of "neutralized" did not apply to al-Sharif. He told the court that there was no justification for the accusations, as soldiers had shot attackers in the head in the past to stop their attacks and prevent them from detonating suicide belts.[44] In response to his claim that al-Sharif posed a threat, the prosecution showed footage of Liebman leisurely walking near al-Sharif with his back turned. Liebman responded by saying that he did not sense a clear and present danger and did not speak about it because it was not his responsibility to assume command from an army officer.[45]

On 29 August, Azaria's platoon commander backed his claim that he feared al-Sharif could detonate a suicide bomb. He also claimed that he warned Na'aman about the bomb threat, but that Na'aman ignored his orders and had posted a soldier to watch over al-Sharif. The prosecution questioned his claims, stating that he did not make any such claims during the investigation and also questioned why he was standing close to al-Sharif during the incident.[46] A police sapper who also testified on the same day stated that the body of a terrorist should be regarded as being booby-trapped until it has been inspected by bomb experts. He also stated that the bodies of stabbers shouldn't be moved until they had been inspected by explosives experts, and that their clothing was appropriate considering the weather during the incident.[47]

On 30 August, Asher Horowitz, a member of Hebron's emergency response team, testified, claiming that it was feared that al-Sharif was booby-trapped because he was wearing a jacket on a hot day. He alleged that Na'aman was a leftist who detested settlers and that his testimony was influenced by his political views.[48]

On 31 August, defense attorneys produced a report by retired pathologist Yehuda Hiss which stated that al-Sharif had died before Azaria shot him in the head and that the movements of his hand shown in footage could have been spasms.[49][50]

On 1 September, Magen David Adom (MDA) paramedic Zahi Yahav testified, saying that he had heard screams that al-Sharif might be booby-trapped and that he had escaped from the area of the incident as he genuinely feared that he could be blown up.[51] On the same day, Azaria's deputy company commander testified and stated that he heard the brigade commander, battalion commander and the battalion commander say that Azaria was lying. He also stated the process was causing concern among the soldiers and might influence their testimonies.[52]

On 5 September, a lieutenant in the Kfir Brigade who was not at the scene said that he found Azaria's belief that al-Sharif was wearing a suicide vest was plausible and that he therefore was justified in killing him. However, during the cross-examination, the prosecution proved that he had only heard Azaria's story after he had already gotten advice from his defense lawyer, with the lieutenant also admitting he had never encountered an explosive vest during his military career. On the same day, surgeon Dov Shimon submitted his opinion that al-Sharif did not die due to Azaria shooting him. Shimon had also requested the court to gag the publication of his name, which was denied. During the cross-examination of Shimon, the prosecutor stated Shimon was an expert in cardiology, not in forensic medicine. He also alleged that Shimon was fired from Hadassah Medical Center for submitting a false medical document in the past, which he claimed was the reason behind Shimon requesting a gag on the publication of his name. Shimon denied this but admitted that he had submitted a forged document to the medical center, claiming it was provided to him by the Ministry of Health. He claimed he was persecuted by his superiors at the medical center.[53][54]

On 11 September, a former chief bomb expert of Israel Police stated that although IDF was supreme in West Bank, the police's bomb squad was responsible for bomb-related issues. Another bomb expert, Ofer Ashkuri, was alleged by the prosecution to have copied his expert report from documents used by the defense. Ashkuri denied the allegation. One of Azaria's former non-commissioned officer junior commanders also testified on his behalf, stating that he was a good soldier, never lost control of his emotions and never made any comments disparaging Palestinians. He also criticized the top three commanders who testified against Azaria as treating him too harshly for making a mistake in what he described as a "chaotic terror scene" where people felt their lives were in danger. He also agreed with the defense's argument that the other soldiers felt influenced to testify against Azaria because of the actions of their commanders.[55]

On 14 September, Ronen Bashari, the deputy director of MDA, said that the area where the shooting occurred was extremely dangerous. He also stated that there had been a change in MDA's regulations to allow a Palestinian attacker's body to be removed under IDF's order before the bomb squad arrives. Later, Yehuda Hiss testified that al-Sharif had died before being shot by Azaria. He also was critical of the analysis of forensic pathologist Gips. Hiss claimed that Gips' analysis of al-Sharif's death was contradicted by medical journals and also accused Gips of not perform all necessary autopsy procedures. Gips disputed Hiss' claims while the prosecution pointed out his admitted involvement in organ harvesting. Later in the day, Yissachar Herman, a psychiatrist, testified that Azaria's judgment was impaired due to him not having slept properly before the incident. The prosecution, however, showed that Azaria had slept for eight hours the night before the incident. Herman also claimed that Azaria had learning disabilities and had told him that he had trouble reading the material from his interrogation. The prosecution, however, showed the court that Azaria had completed the IDF's medic course with a score of 93.[56][57]

Ex-deputy IDF chief Uzi Dayan testified on Azaria's behalf on 19 September, stating that terrorists should be killed even if they don't pose a danger. He also stated that it is up to a soldier in the field to determine whether a situation is dangerous.[58] Reserve General Danny Bitton on the same day also said that the shooting was justified if Azaria thought he was in danger. He also claimed that the military court is not able to determine whether Azaria really felt a danger and that a full military operational investigation wasn't done before the military police started investigating.[59]

On 25 September, a soldier who was injured in the attack testified on Azaria's behalf, stating that there was a legitimate concern for explosives. The prosecution pointed out that he didn't mention any such concern during his first testimony. The soldier acknowledged this, but claimed that he, at the time, was "not at his best". He also admitted that once al-Sharif fell to the ground, he no longer viewed him as a threat. Eli Bin, the head of MDA, also testified on the same day that, according to instructions at the time of the incident, an attacker shouldn't be approached if there is a concern about explosives. He also stated that following subsequent discussions, it was decided that concern about explosives would remain until the outer clothing of the attacker had been removed. The prosecution, however, showed the video of MDA rescue worker Ofer Ohana kicking the knife towards al-Sharif's body. He also questioned the credibility and neutrality of Ben and MDA and presented evidence that some MDA employees had refused to treat Palestinians in the past because of anti-Palestinian ideology.[60][61]

On 27 September, Shmuel Zakai testified on Azaria's behalf, claiming that Azaria didn't shoot to kill and also claimed that the video footage proved Azaria was in danger. He opined that Azaria was afraid of a bomb while criticizing Azaria's company commander Na'aman, stating that the incident would have been avoided had he properly clarified the rules of engagement. Zakai explained that in some operational situations, orders are given that alter the rules of engagement, such as when opening fire would put IDF soldiers at risk, stating Na'aman did not give that order and left the soldier with the previous and unclear rules of engagement.[clarification needed] He also criticized his former brigade commander, Yariv Ben-Ezra, for his orders. Mark Weiser, a psychiatrist who met with Azaria after the incident to assess his mental standing, also testified. He stated that the shooter did not suffer from PTSD, contradicting his attorney's claims. In response to Azaria's accusations that he was collaborating with the prosecution to convict him at any cost and that he had laughed at him, Weiser stated that he told Azaria he wasn't conspiring against him nor had he laughed at him, but might have smiled at him when Azaria said he wanted to harm him as he considered it humorous.[clarification needed][62]

On 26 October, Yoni Bleichbard, the head of settlement security in Hebron, testified for the defense. He said that he wouldn't have reported Azaria's shooting, which he thought was justified. When questioned about Ben-Ezra's testimony that he had reported the incident as irregular, he stated that he didn't know what the commander was thinking and what he understood. He also alleged that Ben-Ezra's testimony was full of contradictions and claimed that the scene was handled improperly, leading to the shooting. He also claimed that he did not remember exactly what he saw Azaria do or what he told the IDF about it. Upon being questioned by the prosecution, he stated that Azaria's lawyer, Eyal Beserglick, had sought his help to "destroy the brigade commander" and he had repeatedly rejected his requests. Beserglick claimed what he said to him was terminology regarding undermining the reliability of the brigade commander. When questioned about Beserglick's message to have him court ordered as well his replies to cause a commotion and not to speak anything if he was forced to be there, he claimed that he did all he could not to come, as he was against the attempt to turn him into a "state liar".

Hadas Gips testified again on the same day. She maintained that Azaria's shot killed al-Sharif. Azaria's lawyers objected, citing the testimony of Yehuda Hiss. They also questioned her objectivity and her expertise, alleging that the IDF prosecution had pushed her in the direction they wanted her to go and doubting that she was an expert in the specific area of the testimony. In response to the claim that she had presented several articles to support her conclusion, she responded that she did so out of professionalism, knowing that there was a counter opinion by Hiss, but that she could have testified without submitting the articles.[63][64][65]

The prosecution submitted its summations on 7 November. It stated that Azaria had lied in his testimony and had changed his story five times. According to the summations, Azaria had never told any of the witnesses who testified that al-Sharif posed a danger, and his motive for shooting al-Sharif was to exact revenge for him stabbing his friend. His claim of feeling threatened was an after-the-fact construction. [66]

Azaria's lawyers submitted their summations on 20 November. It argued that he should be acquitted of all charges because his version of the events had been confirmed during the investigation. It further claimed that Azaria never told anyone that al-Sharif deserved to die and that, in any event, the shot he placed in his head followed intense pressure after a traumatic event. The summations also stated that his worry of a bomb threat was legitimate and that his commanders were the ones to blame. It also questioned whether Colonel Maya Heller, the presiding judge in the trial, could try the case objectively and accused her of being biased against Azaria.[67][68]

The prosecution and the defense team delivered their closing statements on 23 November. Azaria's attorney Ilan Katz called the trial "unwarranted", stating that security forces had shot "neutralized" attackers before, but there was no trial against them. He also criticized former Defense Minister Moshe Ya'alon's remarks that Azaria had "sinned". The prosecutor Colonel Nadav Weisman stated that Azaria shot al-Sharif out of revenge, citing statements from his commanders and a fellow soldier that they heard him say al-Sharif stabbed his friend and needed to die. He further stated that acquitting him would create a dangerous precedent and his actions were illegal, and so should be convicted.[69]

Court verdict and sentencing

The verdict of the military court was scheduled for 4 January 2017.[70] The hearing of the verdict was later relocated to IDF's headquarters in Tel Aviv due to the anticipated crowds and protesters.[71] On 4 January, Azaria was convicted of manslaughter by a panel of three judges. The verdict was announced by Central Command Chief Justice Colonel Maya Heller.[72] The sentencing was originally scheduled for 15 January.[73] Channel 2 claimed that IDF had held a meeting with the shooter's father on the previous day, asking him to drop the appeal and fire their attorneys, which would be taken into consideration for a pardon. He was also reportedly offered to meet with senior IDF officials for a plea bargain. Azaria's defense team, in a letter to Lieberman, called this a criminal offense. The IDF, however, denied that they had made any such offer and stated that the meeting was held to ask his family if it needed any assistance. The defense team called the denial a lie.[74] The court acceded to the defense team's request for postponement of sentencing discussions on 11 January, shifting it to a week and a half later.[75]

During the sentencing hearing on 24 January, Azaria's defense team asked the court to toss out the manslaughter conviction over the alleged offer by the IDF to his father for a lenient sentence, claiming "tampering" with legal proceedings. The court rejected this request and stated that the hearings would continue but that it would revisit the allegations later.[76] His father also appealed for lenient sentencing, asking the court to consider Azaria's service and character as well as the physical and psychological health problems being faced by the family since the trial began. He claimed that his son had also received death threats from Palestinians. He also stated that he had been given an offer of lenient sentencing for his son and requested the court to sentence his son to time already served in open arrest on his base.[77][78] Several witnesses also testified for his character.[79] The prosecution asked the court to sentence Azaria to a prison term of three to five years during a hearing on 31 January. It also asked that his rank to be demoted to private.[80] Colonel Guy Hazut, commander of Kfir Brigade, stated that what Azaria had done was serious and that he should be punished, but stated that the punishment shouldn't be severe. He accepted a meeting with Azaria's father but denied he had any discussion with him about the appeal or a reduction in punishment.[81][82]

On 21 February, the court delivered Azaria's sentence. Regarding Hazut's meeting with Azaria's father, it ruled that he had good intentions for the meeting even though he was misguided and thought Azaria would get less prison time if he expressed regret than if he filed an appeal. The court took Azaria's character and the situation at the time of the shooting into account, sentencing him to a prison term of one year and six months, 12 month probation thereafter, in addition to a rank demotion to private.[83][1]

Appeal

Azaria filed for an appeal against the decision on 1 March. Most of his defense team also quit in protest. His father and his only remaining lawyer claimed later that during a meeting between Major General Sharon Afek and Azaria's main defense lawyers Ilan Katz and Eyal Besserglick, they had been threatened that if they appealed against the verdict, the IDF would file a counter-appeal for a stricter sentence. The IDF and both Katz and Besserglick denied this.[84] The start of Azaria's sentence, scheduled for 5 March, was also postponed by the Military Court of Appeals pending the result of the appeal.[85] The military prosecution filed an appeal on 7 March to increase the length of Azaria's sentence, which they considered to be "lenient".[86] The first hearing of Azaria's appeal began on 3 May.[87] In mid-July, as his military service had been completed, he was allowed to return home and remain under house arrest until his appeal was heard.[88]

Azaria's appeal was rejected on 30 July by the military court, which also rejected a request by military prosecutors to increase the length of his sentence.[89] Judges declared that his version of events was unreliable and were also quoted saying that the original reason for him to kill al-Sharif was revenge.[90] Azaria appealed to IDF Chief of Staff Gadi Eizenkot for leniency on 3 August while standing by his claim that he believed al-Sharif had an explosive device.[91] His attorneys submitted an official request to the Military Court of Appeals to delay his prison sentence until Chief of Staff Eizenkot ruled on whether to commute his sentence.[92] Azaria's request to delay the start of his sentence was rejected on 8 August, with the court citing a 2010 ruling that a pardon request is not sufficient grounds for delaying the start of a prison term and also stated that sentences are to begin immediately after being handed down.[93]

On September 27, Eisenkot reduced Azaria's sentence from 18 months to 14 months.[94] Eisenkot stated that while he did not approve of his actions, he nonetheless reduced the sentence out of considerations for compassion, mercy and Azaria's combat service, and that a message had been sent to all soldiers to not to act like him.[95] Azaria submitted a pardon request to President Reuven Rivlin on October 19.[96] Rivlin's office, however, issued a statement on November 19, saying that the appeal had been rejected, adding that he had taken into account both the offenses committed by Azaria and their circumstances.[97]

Another pardon appeal, this time by his parents, was turned down on 24 December by the President, who stated that a new request could be made only six months after the previous decision.[98]

Imprisonment and aftermath

Azaria began his prison term on 9 August at Prison Four.[99] He was released on 8 May 2018 after serving nine months of his sentence following a parole board order.[100] Azaria term was shortened by two additional days, after prison commanders granted him an early release to attend his brother's wedding, in accordance with regulations that allow for early release in such circumstances.[101]

In accordance with a decision the IDF made in October 2017, about half of Azaria's discharge pay was withheld as a result of his conviction. Azaria, who would have originally been entitled to NIS 48,000 ($13,720), received NIS 24,000 ($6,860) instead.[102]

Reactions

The shooting immediately drew widespread condemnation, including from the Israeli Defense Minister at that time, Moshe Ya'alon, and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who called it a violation of the IDF's ethical code. Ya'alon said, "The incident is highly severe, and completely contrary to the IDF's values and its combat morals. We must not allow, even as our blood boils, such a loss of faculties and control. This incident will be dealt with in the strictest manner." Netanyahu also called criticism of the army over the shooting "outrageous". IDF Spokesperson Brigadier General Moti Almoz said it was "a very severe incident. This is not the IDF culture or the Jewish people's culture." The controversy turned into a bitter political debate, splitting Israel's right-wing government and inspiring demonstrations in Ramle and Beit Shemesh in support Azaria, whose identity had yet to be made public. Azaria has also attracted widespread support on Israeli social media, with more than 13,000 people joining Facebook support groups and another 50,000 signing a petition backing his actions. Supporters of the soldier posted a video online of the moments before the shooting, which they say shows supports the soldier's claim that he feared the assailant may have had an explosive device. The two most prominent figures who have given vocal support to Azaria and his family have been the right-wing Israeli education minister, Naftali Bennett, whose "The Jewish Home" party organized the demonstration in the city of Ramle, and the former Minister of Foreign Affairs, Avigdor Lieberman. Israeli lawmakers from the center-left reacted harshly, warning of the dangers of moral decline and of loose rules of engagement in the military.[13][103]

On 31 March 2016, Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas commented on the killing in an interview with Ilana Dayan sent on Israeli TV: "This is inhumane, to shoot a living man. I don't want to blame the entire Israeli people. I know, the Israelis are human beings. They are humane. But unfortunately, we read the responses and the protests in Israel against putting the soldier on trial, against arresting him. Such statements are disturbing and frustrate us a great deal."[104] On the same date, Netanyahu spoke with Azaria's father, stating that he understood his distress as he himself was a father of a soldier. He also reassured him that the difficult situations faced by soldiers confronting terrorists would be taken into account and that the system would be fair to his son.[105]

On 6 April, IDF Chief of Staff Gadi Eizenkot stated during a meeting with soldiers at the Tze'elim camp that the shooting ran counter to the professional and ethical norms of behavior demanded of IDF troops.[106]

Demonstration in support of Azaria in Rabin Square. Translation of text on the poster: "If we don't protect our soldiers, who will protect us?"

A demonstration in support of Azaria was organised by his family and former Knesset member Sharon Gal in Tel Aviv's Rabin Square on 19 April. Singers Eyal Golan and David D'or and rapper Subliminal were slated to perform at the rally. However, Golan and D'or pulled out of the rally, citing the rally becoming politicized as the reason. The organizers had hoped for a large crowd numbering tens of thousands. However, the rally drew only an estimated 2,000 people. The rally was attended by a number of pop icons, public figures and extremist figures.[21][107][108] On 19 April, Netanyahu urged for "balance" in Azaria's trial and said that he was sure the court would act wisely in weighing Azaria's killing of al-Sharif and the context in which he did so.[109] On 25 July, Defence Minister Avigdor Lieberman said the government must not express a stance on the shooting until the end of the trial and also criticized the earlier reaction of his predecessor Ya'alon.[110] On 12 September, Lieberman stated that he would support Azaria even if he was convicted and urged the court to "ignore the noise" and judge according to the facts.[111]

During an interview with Channel 2 News, Netanyahu stated he had no regrets about calling Azaria's parents. When questioned whether he had made telephone calls to parents of other soldiers who had transgressed, he replied that he hadn't but had talked to those parents of soldiers who were killed or missing. Netanyahu was criticized by opposition politicians and the media for comparing the parents of fallen soldiers to parents of soldiers charged criminal conduct, like Azaria's. The Prime Minister's Office later issued a statement rejecting these claims and called them a "base, distorted and lying" misrepresentation. Netanyahu himself also denied these claims, saying words had been misunderstood or misinterpreted.[112][113]

On 8 October, Bennett called for an immediate pardon of Azaria if convicted because it was important to back soldiers in their efforts to "protect Israel from terrorists". He also raised doubts that Azaria was receiving a fair trial. His statements were criticized by Zionist Union MK Eyal Ben-Reuven as well as Yesh Atid MK Elazar Stern, both former soldiers.[114]

Moti Almoz, in response to criticism leveled at him for his statements regarding the incident, stated on 14 November that he had no regrets about denouncing Azaria. He defended the handling of the incident by senior IDF officers, claiming it couldn't have remained within the army. He also criticized Israeli politicians who had criticized the IDF for putting Azaria on trial.[115]

On 28 December, former defense minister Moshe Ya'alon criticized politicians who praised Azaria and attacked him, Netanyahu, and the IDF. He also criticized Netanyahu for switching his opinion about the shooting and "embracing" Azaria. He also condemned Azaria's actions during the incident.[116]

On 1 January 2017, Azaria's defense team wrote a letter to Lieberman in which it asked for a state investigation into the trial, claiming that due process had been compromised. They cited public comments made after the shooting by IDF Chief of Staff Eizenkot, the IDF Spokesperson's Unit and then-Defense Minister Moshe Ya'alon, as well as the fact that Azaria was not present for the preliminary operational review following the incident. They also claimed that an unnamed senior military official who was quoted by Channel 10 News as saying that Azaria would be convicted was the Military Advocate General, who was trying to influence the decision of the judges. The IDF Spokesperson's Unit rejected these accusations as baseless and incorrect while military officials stated that the Military Advocate General Sharon Afek had never made any such comments.[71]

Human Rights Watch blamed Israeli officials for the incident on 2 January, stating that they encouraged soldiers and police officers to kill Palestinians they suspect of attacking Israelis even when they no longer pose a threat.[117]

On 3 January, Eizenkot criticized those depicting the shooter as a "confused little kid", saying this demeaned the army's character.[118] Former IDF Chief of Staff Benny Gantz as well as 53 reserve battalion commander supported his statements.[119]

After the verdict was announced, many Israeli politicians including Netanyahu called for Azaria to be pardoned while others accused the Israeli military of "abandoning" him. Protests also erupted outside the courthouse in response to the verdict.[120] The Palestinian Authority meanwhile called the trial "farcical", alleging that the Israeli government was trying to "deflect attention from its wide crimes."[121] The Palestinian cameraman who recorded the incident claimed that he had received threats to his life[122] and was also attacked by Israeli settlers.[123] After reports emerged that some soldiers at the scene of the January 2017 Jerusalem truck attack had fled and hesitated in firing at the truck, some right-wing commenters alleged that they hadn't quickly responded because of the court verdict given in Azaria's case, fearing they would face similar punishment.[124][125] The IDF, however, stated that at least two soldiers fired at the attacker, and denied a connection between troops' response to the case, as did a cadet who was present at the incident.[125][126][127] Dozens of people illegally protested against the conviction outside the residence of the President of Israel on 8 January. At least seven protesters were arrested for public order offenses.[128]

General Eyal Zamir, head of Southern Command, stated on 10 January at the Haifa Leadership Conference that Azaria committed a criminal offense, but it was a threshold. He also stated the IDF couldn't compromise its values or it will lose its morality. Colonel Nimrod Aloni, commander of Paratroopers Brigade, reiterated the need to follow the rules of engagement at the forum.[129] Defense Minister Lieberman later called on people to calm down regarding the verdict while telling them to remember that Azaria is an excellent soldier and that al-Sharif was a terrorist who came to murder Jews. He also stated that everything was being done to guard IDF's values and Azaria.[130]

After the sentencing, several ministers called for Azaria to be pardoned. Meanwhile, al-Sharif's father criticized the sentence as a "joke" and his family claimed that Palestinians were jailed longer for stone-throwing. Protests continued outside the courthouse as Azaria was sentenced.[131][132][133] Netanyahu also backed a pardon for Azaria, saying that it is important to consider the "challenging circumstances" young soldiers face.[134] Some human rights organisations and Palestinian leaders criticized the sentencing as overly lenient.[135] The Arab League also criticized the length of the sentence, alleging it showed "racism",[136] while Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights called it "excessively lenient" and "unacceptable".[137] On 12 March, revelers in a Hebron settlement paid tribute to Azaria during a parade organized to commemorate Purim.[138]

In 2024 the United States imposed visa restrictions on Azaria and his family, blocking them from entry into the United States. State Department spokesperson Matthew Miller explained that the restrictions were imposed for "gross violations of human rights."[139]

References

  1. ^ a b "Sgt. Elor Azaria sentenced to 18 months in prison". Ynetnews. Retrieved 2017-02-21.
  2. ^ Bob, Yonah Jeremy; Zieve, Tamara (8 May 2018). "Hebron shooter Elor Azaria released after 9 months in prison". The Jerusalem Post. Retrieved 2018-05-09.
  3. ^ Ari Gross, Judah (24 March 2016). "Soldier moderately hurt in Hebron stabbing; attackers killed". The Times of Israel. Retrieved 3 April 2016.
  4. ^ "Name of soldier accused of manslaughter in Hebron shooting released". The Jerusalem Post. 18 April 2016.
  5. ^ Cohen, Gili (31 March 2016). "Charges Against IDF Soldier Who Shot Subdued Palestinian Downgraded to Manslaughter". Haaretz.
  6. ^ a b Levy, Elinor; Zitun, Yoav; Kimon, Ben (24 March 2016). "WATCH: IDF soldier shoots neutralized terrorist in the head". Ynet. Retrieved 3 April 2016.
  7. ^ a b "New video corroborates Hebron soldier's testimony, supporters say". The Times of Israel. 24 March 2016. Retrieved 3 April 2016.
  8. ^ Ifergan, Moshe (June 28, 2016). "עדות המ"פ לא מותירה ספק: אלאור אזריה זכאי". מידה.
  9. ^ Levy, Elior; Elizera, Rotem (3 April 2016). "Pathologists: Soldier's bullet killed Hebron terrorist". Ynet. Retrieved 3 April 2016.
  10. ^ "Azaria mate: Elor said terrorist deserved to die". Times of Israel. 11 July 2016. Retrieved 2016-07-18.
  11. ^ Yehoshua, Yossi; Zitun, Yoav (24 July 2016). "Azaria: 'I shot the terrorist because I sensed clear and present danger'". Ynetnews. Retrieved 2016-07-24.
  12. ^ Cohen, Gili (27 March 2016). "Soldier Said Palestinian Assailant 'Needs to Die' Before Shooting, Army Probe Finds". Haaretz.
  13. ^ a b Beaumont, Peter (29 March 2016). "Most Israelis support soldier accused of shooting Palestinian, says poll". The Guardian. Retrieved 3 April 2016.
  14. ^ Cohen, Gili (31 March 2016). "Charges Against IDF Soldier Who Shot Subdued Palestinian Downgraded to Manslaughter". Haaretz. Retrieved 23 November 2016.
  15. ^ "Israeli soldier filmed shooting Palestinian released to open arrest". i24news. 1 April 2016. Retrieved 23 November 2016.
  16. ^ "Soldier who killed disarmed Palestinian won't go back to jail". Times of Israel. 5 April 2016. Retrieved 23 November 2016.
  17. ^ Levy, Elior; Elizera, Rotem (3 April 2016). "Pathologists: Soldier's bullet killed Hebron terrorist". Ynetnews. Retrieved 2016-06-13.
  18. ^ חורי, ג'קי; אפרתי, עידו; כהן, גילי (2016-04-03). "הרופאים שערכו את הנתיחה מסכימים: המחבל מחברון מת מהירי לראשו". הארץ (in Hebrew). Retrieved 2016-06-13.
  19. ^ Bob, Yonah Jeremy (2016-08-03). "Palestinian autopsy observer: Shooting by soldier suspected of manslaughter was killing shot". The Jerusalem Post. Retrieved 2016-08-30.
  20. ^ Cohen, Gili (14 April 2016). "Soldier who shot subdued Palestinian assailant in Hebron to be charged with manslaughter". Haaretz. Retrieved 16 April 2016.
  21. ^ a b Sterman, Adiv; Gross, Judah Ari (19 April 2016). "Tel Aviv rally for Hebron shooter draws fewer than expected". Times of Israel.
  22. ^ "IDF investigators 'say Hebron soldier motivated by twisted ideology'". Times of Israel.
  23. ^ Bob, Yonah Jeremy (9 May 2016). "Hebron shooter to remain in detention for Independence Day". The Jerusalem Post.
  24. ^ Winer, Stuart. "Hebron shooting soldier denies manslaughter charge". Times of Israel.
  25. ^ "Funeral to be held for terrorist killed in Hebron shooting". The Jerusalem Post. 28 May 2016.
  26. ^ Amir, Noam (29 May 2016). "Hebron shooter's lawyers: Bring terrorist's body back to Israel". The Jerusalem Post.
  27. ^ Bob, Yonah Jeremy (1 June 2016). "IDF finds ambulance driver moved knife closer to Hebron attacker after shooting". The Jerusalem Post.
  28. ^ Dearden, Lizzie (June 3, 2016). "Footage shows 'settler kicking knife towards Palestinian man's body'". The Independent.
  29. ^ Khoury, Jack (6 June 2016). "Second Assailant in Notorious Hebron Shooting Also Executed, Eyewitnesses Say". Haaretz.
  30. ^ Cohen, Gili (8 June 2016). "Video of Israeli Soldier Shooting Subdued Assailant in Hebron Wasn't Tampered With, Expert Says". Haaretz.
  31. ^ a b Glanz, James (2016-06-16). "Palestinian Killed by Israeli Soldier Posed No Danger, Commander Testifies". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Archived from the original on 18 June 2016. Retrieved 2023-04-22.
  32. ^ Blumenthal, Itay (2016-06-16). "Pathologist testifies that terrorist was alive when Hebron soldier shot him". Ynetnews. Retrieved 2016-11-23.
  33. ^ Cohen, Gili (2016-07-05). "Medic at Hebron soldier's manslaughter trial refuses to answer". Haaretz. Retrieved 2016-08-17.
  34. ^ Bob, Yonah Jeremy (2016-07-05). "Prosecutor accuses activist, soldier of cover-up in Hebron shooter trial". Jerusalem Post. Retrieved 2016-08-17.
  35. ^ "Brigade chief: Hebron soldier was wrong to kill attacker". The Times of Israel. 2016-07-06. Retrieved 2016-08-17.
  36. ^ Cohen, Gili (2016-07-11). "Hebron shooting witness says saw soldier cock gun, 'but didn't think he was going to shoot'". Haaretz. Retrieved 2016-08-17.
  37. ^ Cohen, Gili (2016-07-12). "Hebron shooter's commander says soldier did not mention bomb threat". Haaretz. Retrieved 2016-08-17.
  38. ^ Zitun, Yoav (2016-07-12). "Battalion commander: 'I felt Elor was not telling me the truth'". Ynet News. Retrieved 2016-08-17.
  39. ^ Mitnick, Joshua (2016-07-24). "My commanders lied: Israeli soldier in court over killing of Palestinian". The Sydney Morning Herald. Archived from the original on 28 July 2016. Retrieved 2016-08-17.
  40. ^ Bob, Yonah Jeremy (2016-07-25). "Hebron shooter confesses: The knife was not near al-Sharif like I told police". The Jerusalem Post. Retrieved 2016-08-17.
  41. ^ Zitun, Yoav; Bnaya, Yehonatan (2016-07-26). "Sgt. Elor Azaria grilled in court for third day". Ynet News. Retrieved 2016-08-17.
  42. ^ Zitun, Yoav; Bnaya, Yehonatan (2016-07-26). "Judge to Azaria: 'Why didn't you shoot earlier?'". Ynet News. Retrieved 2016-08-17.
  43. ^ "There was justification to open fire". Israel National News. 2016-08-23. Retrieved 2016-11-23.
  44. ^ "Hebron soldier was right to shoot, civilian security official testifies". Times of Israel. 2016-08-28. Retrieved 2016-08-30.
  45. ^ "Witnesses testify in defense of IDF soldier on trial for manslaughter". i24news. 2016-08-28. Retrieved 2016-08-30.
  46. ^ Winer, Stuart (2016-08-29). "Hebron soldier's commander: There was concern about a bomb". Times of Israel. Retrieved 2016-08-30.
  47. ^ Cohen, Gili (2016-08-29). "Soldiers' anger led IDF officers to fear mutiny after Hebron shooting, court hears". Harretz. Retrieved 2016-09-03.
  48. ^ Lior, Ilan (2016-08-30). "Defending Hebron shooter, witness says IDF commanders have political motives". Haaretz. Retrieved 2016-08-30.
  49. ^ "Former Chief Pathologist: Hebron Terrorist Was Already Dead When Azaria Shot Him". Jewish Press. 2016-09-01. Retrieved 2016-09-03.
  50. ^ Shoval, Lilach (2016-09-01). "In legal twist, expert says terrorist shot in Hebron was already dead". Israel Hayom. Retrieved 2016-09-03.
  51. ^ Blumenthal, Itay (2016-09-01). "Paramedic in Azaria trial: 'I was genuinely scared of being blown up.'". Ynetnews. Retrieved 2016-09-03.
  52. ^ Blumenthal, Itay; Zitun, Yoav (2016-09-01). "Azaria's deputy company commander testifies on his behalf". Ynetnews. Retrieved 2016-09-03.
  53. ^ Berger, Yotam (2016-09-06). "Medical witness in Hebron shooting trial: Shot fired by Azaria did not kill Palestinian". Haaretz. Retrieved 2016-09-06.
  54. ^ Bob, Yonah Jeremy (2016-09-06). "IDF lieutenant: Hebron shooter was justified if terrorist had worn bomb". The Jerusalem Post. Retrieved 2016-09-06.
  55. ^ Bob, Yonah Jeremy (2016-09-11). "Hebron shooter trial: Who is in charge of bombs in the West Bank – the IDF or police?". The Jerusalem Post. Retrieved 2016-09-12.
  56. ^ Cohen, Gili (2016-09-15). "At Azaria's trial, expert says autopsy fails to show head shot killed Palestinian". Haaretz. Retrieved 2016-09-18.
  57. ^ Bob, Yonah Jeremy (2016-09-15). "Defense expert: Azaria did not kill Palestinian attacker". The Jerusalem Post. Retrieved 2016-09-18.
  58. ^ Surkes, Sue (2016-09-19). "Terrorists must be killed, ex-deputy IDF head tells Hebron shooter trial". Times of Israel. Retrieved 2016-09-23.
  59. ^ "Commanders are evading responsibility". Arutz Sheva. 2016-09-19. Retrieved 2016-09-23.
  60. ^ Cohen, Gili (2016-09-25). "'The concern about explosives was real,' wounded soldier says at Hebron shooter's trial". Haaretz. Retrieved 2016-09-25.
  61. ^ Bob, Yonah Jeremy (2016-09-25). "Soldier at Hebron shooter trial: Terrorist may have exploded at any moment". The Jerusalem Post. Retrieved 2016-09-26.
  62. ^ Blumental, Itay (2016-09-27). "Former Gaza Division commander: 'Azaria didn't shoot to kill'". YNet News. Retrieved 2016-11-23.
  63. ^ Cohen, Gili (2016-10-26). "Hebron Settlement Security Chief: Sgt. Azaria Was Right to Shoot Subdued Assailant". Haaretz. Retrieved 2016-11-23.
  64. ^ Bob, Yonah Jeremy (2016-10-26). "Eyewitness to Hebron shooting says incident could have been prevented". Jerusalem Post. Retrieved 2016-11-23.
  65. ^ Zitun, Yoav (2016-10-26). "Sgt. Azaria's lawyer sought witness's help to 'destroy brigade commander'". Ynetnews. Retrieved 2016-11-23.
  66. ^ Cohen, Gili (2016-11-07). "Hebron Shooter's Lies Are Enough to Destroy His Defense, Says IDF Prosecution". Haaretz. Retrieved 2016-11-23.
  67. ^ Ahronheim, Anna (2016-11-20). "Hebron shooter's defense team wraps up, asks court to acquit Elor Azaria of all charges". Jerusalem Post. Retrieved 2016-11-23.
  68. ^ Cohen, Gili (2016-11-20). "Israeli Soldier's Lawyers Accuse Judge of Bias in Hebron Shooting Case". Haaretz. Retrieved 2016-11-23.
  69. ^ Cohen, Gili (2016-11-24). "Israeli Soldier's Attorney Asserts Trial on Controversial Hebron Shooting Was Unwarranted". Haaretz. Retrieved 2016-11-24.
  70. ^ Bob, Yonah Jeremy (2 January 2017) [30 December 2016]. "Rule of Law: Verdict time for Azaria". The Jerusalem Post. Archived from the original on 4 May 2023. Retrieved 7 January 2017.
  71. ^ a b Shoval, Lilach (2 January 2017). "Defense in Hebron shooting case calls for state inquiry". Israel Hayom. Retrieved 9 January 2017.
  72. ^ Yoav Zitun and Yonatan Baniyeh (2017-01-04). "Sgt. Elor Azaria convicted of manslaughter after Hebron shooting". Ynetnews. Retrieved 2017-01-04.
  73. ^ "Police arrest 7 at impromptu Jerusalem rally for Hebron shooter". Times of Israel. 2017-01-08. Retrieved 2017-01-09.
  74. ^ Winer, Stuart (11 January 2017). "Controversy: IDF accused of arranging covert meeting with Elor Azaria's father". Al-Bawaba.
  75. ^ Zeyton, Yoav (2017-01-11). "השיחה נחשפה: המח"ט הציע לאביו של אזריה עסקה לסיוע משפטי". Ynetnews (in Hebrew). Retrieved 2017-01-16.
  76. ^ Bob, Yonah Jeremy (2017-01-24). "Hebron shooter's team asks court to toss verdict over alleged tampering". Jerusalem Post. Retrieved 2017-01-25.
  77. ^ "'We've suffered enough': Father of Hebron soldier appeals for leniency". Times of Israel. 2017-01-24. Retrieved 2017-01-25.
  78. ^ "Sentencing hearing held in controversial IDF soldier manslaughter trial". i24 News. 2017-01-24. Retrieved 2017-01-25.
  79. ^ "Father of Israel soldier convicted of manslaughter pleads for leniency". Gulf Times. 2017-01-24. Retrieved 2017-01-25.
  80. ^ Cohen, Gili (2017-01-31). "Military Prosecution Seeks 3-5 Years for Israeli Soldier Who Killed Palestinian Attacker". Haaretz. Retrieved 2017-01-31.
  81. ^ "Israel prosecution seeks 3-5 years for soldier who killed Palestinian". Yahoo! News. 2017-01-31. Archived from the original on 31 January 2017. Retrieved 2017-01-31.
  82. ^ Ravid, Or (2017-01-31). "מח"ט כפיר במשפט אזריה: "טעיתי כשהבטחתי לאביו שיפגוש בכירים בצה"ל"". Walla!. Retrieved 2017-01-31.
  83. ^ Bob, Yonah Jeremy (2017-02-21). "IDF court sentences Hebron shooter to 1.5-year jail term". Jerusalem Post. Retrieved 2017-02-21.
  84. ^ Bob, Yonah Jeremy (2017-03-03). "Hebron shooter appeals manslaughter conviction". Jerusalem Post. Retrieved 2017-03-03.
  85. ^ "Elor Azaria: Israeli soldier's jailing delayed amid appeal". Jerusalem Post. 2017-03-02. Retrieved 2017-03-02.
  86. ^ "Israeli army prosecutors appeal 'lenient' sentence for Hebron shooter Azaria". i24 News. 2017-03-07. Retrieved 2017-03-17.
  87. ^ Zitun, Yoav (2017-05-03). "Elor Azaria's appeal begins with first hearing". Ynetnews. Retrieved 2017-05-11.
  88. ^ "Israeli soldier who shot dead wounded Palestinian attacker is under house arrest after three months in prison". The Independent. 2017-07-18. Archived from the original on 2022-05-09. Retrieved 2017-07-23.
  89. ^ Kershner, Isabel (30 July 2017). "Israel Court Rejects Appeal for Elor Azaria, Soldier Who Shot Wounded Assailant". The New York Times. Retrieved 11 August 2017.
  90. ^ "Israeli soldier who killed wounded Palestinian attacker loses appeal". BBC News. 30 July 2017.
  91. ^ Gross, Judah Ari (3 August 2017). "Hebron shooter asks IDF chief for leniency, but sticks to story". Times of Israel.
  92. ^ Magid, Jacob (6 August 2017). "Hebron shooter seeks to delay prison entry until ruling from army chief". Times of Israel.
  93. ^ "Hebron shooter to enter prison after bid to delay sentence rejected". The Times of Israel. 8 August 2017.
  94. ^ Amos Harel (September 27, 2017). "Israeli Army Chief Cuts Hebron Shooter's Sentence by Four Months". Haaretz.
  95. ^ Bob, Yonah Jeremy (September 27, 2017). "Army Chief Cuts 4 Months from hebron Shooter's Sentence". Jerusalem Post.
  96. ^ Fulbright, Alexander; Gross, Judah Ari (October 19, 2017). "Hebron shooter Elor Azaria asks president for pardon". Times of Israel.
  97. ^ "Israeli president rejects pardon for soldier Elor Azaria". BBC. November 19, 2017.
  98. ^ "New pardon request of Israeli soldier Azaria denied by President Rivlin". i24News. December 24, 2017.
  99. ^ Alon, Amir; Blumenthal, Itay; Chai, Shahar (9 August 2017). "Azaria greeted by supporters as he begins prison sentence". Ynetnews.
  100. ^ Bob, Yonah Jeremy (19 March 2018). "IDF Parole Board orders early release of Hebron shooter Elor Azaria". The Jerusalem Post. Retrieved 2023-04-22.
  101. ^ Zitun, Yoav (19 March 2018). "Azaria's sentence cut by third, to be released May 10". Ynetnews.
  102. ^ Surkes, Sue (11 October 2017). "Army to withhold part of Elor Azaria's discharge grant". The Times of Israel.
  103. ^ "Netanyahu defends Israeli army after soldier shot wounded Palestinian". news.yahoo.com. Archived from the original on 27 March 2016.
  104. ^ Ravid, Barak (31 March 2016). "Abbas: Security Coordination With Israel Preventing 'A Bloody Intifada'". Haaretz.
  105. ^ Ravid, Barak (31 March 2016). "Netanyahu Reassures Father of Soldier Who Shot to Death Prone Palestinian". Haaretz. Retrieved 2023-04-22.
  106. ^ Mualem, Mazal (April 11, 2016). "How Hebron shooting highlights shift in Israeli society". Al-Monitor.
  107. ^ "Top-tier singers to headline Tel Aviv rally for Hebron soldier". Times of Israel.
  108. ^ Pileggi, Tamar (18 April 2016). "Pop singers pull out of 'politicized' rally for Hebron soldier". Times of Israel.
  109. ^ Pileggi, Tamar (19 April 2016). "Netanyahu urges 'balance' in trial for Hebron shooter". Times of Israel.
  110. ^ Lappin, Yaakov (25 July 2016). "Liberman: Government mustn't have stance on Hebron shooter until trial's end". The Jerusalem Post. Retrieved 2023-04-22.
  111. ^ "Minister vows to 'stand by' soldier tried for Hebron shooting". www.israelhayom.co.il. Retrieved 2023-04-22.
  112. ^ Eichner, Itamar (2016-09-25). "Netanyahu denies comparing fallen soldiers' parents to Sgt. Elor Azaria's family". Ynetnews. Retrieved 2023-04-22.
  113. ^ Keinon, Herb (26 September 2016). "Netanyahu: I didn't compare Azaria's parents to those of fallen soldiers". The Jerusalem Post. Retrieved 2023-04-22.
  114. ^ Hoffman, Gil (8 October 2016). "Bennett calls for pardoning Hebron shooter". The Jerusalem Post. Retrieved 2023-04-22.
  115. ^ "IDF spokesman: 'No regrets' about denouncing Elor Azaria". Times of Israel. Retrieved 2023-04-22.
  116. ^ "Ex-defense minister slams Netanyahu over Azaria trial". Times of Israel.
  117. ^ Bob, Yonah Jeremy (3 January 2017). "Israeli officials to blame for Hebron shooting, says Human Rights Watch". The Jerusalem Post. Retrieved 2023-04-22.
  118. ^ Cohen, Gili (3 January 2017). "IDF Chief on Hebron Shooter's Trial: Treating a Soldier Like a 'Confused Little Boy' Demeans the Army". Haaretz. Retrieved 2023-04-22.
  119. ^ Cohen, Gili (7 January 2016). "IDF Chief Gets Support From His Predecessor for Critical Line Against Hebron Shooter". Haaretz.
  120. ^ Beaumont, Peter (4 January 2017). "Netanyahu backs calls for convicted Israeli soldier to be pardoned". The Guardian. Retrieved 9 January 2017.
  121. ^ "After manslaughter conviction, PA calls Hebron shooter trial 'farce'". Times of Israel. 4 January 2017. Retrieved 14 January 2017.
  122. ^ Hass, Amira (5 January 2017). "Cameraman in Hebron Shooting: Threats Continuing, Azaria's Supporters Came to My House". Haaretz. Retrieved 9 January 2017.
  123. ^ "Attacks on Palestinian activist who filmed Hebron shooting". Middle East Monitor Online. 8 January 2017. Retrieved 9 January 2017.
  124. ^ Shoval, Lilach (9 January 2017). "'Embarrassing' response by soldiers at scene of attack spurs dispute". Israel Hayom. Retrieved 9 January 2017.
  125. ^ a b Yanovasky, Roi; Efraim, Omri (8 January 2017). "Four IDF soldiers murdered in terror attack in Jerusalem's East Talpiot". Ynetnews. Retrieved 8 January 2017.
  126. ^ "WATCH: IDF says 2 soldiers fired at attacker, despite report of hesitation". Times of israel.
  127. ^ Zitun, Yoav (8 January 2017). "Cadet from Jerusalem attack: We fought for our friends". Ynetnews.
  128. ^ "Arrests after protests against Elor Azaria conviction". Al-Jazeera.
  129. ^ Zitun, Yoav (10 January 2017). "IDF brass discuss Azaria in Haifa leadership conference". Ynetnews.
  130. ^ Zitun, Yoav (10 January 2017). "Lieberman: We are protecting IDF values and Elor Azaria". Ynetnews.
  131. ^ "Israeli soldier gets 18 months for killing wounded Palestinian attacker". BBC. 21 February 2017.
  132. ^ Khoury, Jack (21 February 2017). "Hebron Shooting: 'Palestinian Kids Get Harsher Sentences for Throwing Stones". Haaretz.
  133. ^ "Deputy Foreign Minister: Pardon Elor Azariya". Arutz Sheva. 22 February 2017.
  134. ^ "Netanyahu in favor of pardoning IDF soldier Azaria after manslaughter sentencing". i24news.
  135. ^ Cook, Jonathan (22 February 2017). "Elor Azaria verdict: 'No justice for Palestinians'". Al-Jazeera.
  136. ^ "Arab League denounces 'racist' 18-month sentence for Hebron shooter". Times of Israel. 22 February 2017.
  137. ^ "UN Human Rights Office: Sentence Handed to Hebron Shooter Is 'Unacceptable'". Haaretz. 24 February 2017.
  138. ^ "Hebron parade features tributes to Israeli soldier convicted of killing". Middle East Eye. 17 March 2017.
  139. ^ Hansler, Jennifer (July 17, 2024). "US imposes visa restrictions on former IDF sergeant for human rights violation". CNN.

31°31′25″N 35°06′13″E / 31.5236°N 35.1037°E / 31.5236; 35.1037

Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Killing_of_Abdel_Fattah_al-Sharif&oldid=1241042579"